.png){kind=small}
E is For Empathy & P is For Perspective
Updated: Aug 27
We are taking a little detour this week from our normal content to explore the impact that adults can have on children, and vice versa. The events are based on a true story and shared with permission. Names have been changed except for the names of the schools involved. If you embark on this journey, try to hold in mind the powers of both perspective and empathy.
The Naïve Meet-Cute
Her name was Julie Carmichael. She was less than four feet tall, with skin as dark as rich umber, a perfectly round little face with dimples in her cheeks deep enough to lose the tip of your finger in, and a smile that spread across her face almost wetting her earlobes. Julie was only five years old when I nervously walked into her life supposedly about to teach her, and the other children in her classroom, about literacy and basic mathematics, but that is not exactly how things happened.
I had the opportunity to interview for what I thought would be the best job on earth, a tutor at an elementary school. Apparently, one of the many surveys that I had filled out while I was applying to college returned the results that I’d be great at working with children. The community center at my school was starting a program for America’s youths organized by former President Clinton called ‘America Reads’. I interviewed with the community service program leader Chris Bollington. I remember having to go to his office in between classes one chilly September day. Nervous does not even convey what I was feeling. I was horrified by the possibility that I would not get the job. Chris, as I was told to call him, seemed almost as nervous as I was. (He was a young White guy just graduating from college himself and I was the first interview that he had to conduct). His voice cracked as he spoke to me as if he were a pubescent teenage boy speaking in front of a large group of people. His palm was sweaty -soaked, when he reached out to shake my hand. Even his knee was quickly bouncing at its own, unheard, musical beat. During the interview Chris explained to me what my duties would entail if he were to pick me for the position.
“Are you aware of how much responsibility you would be taking on as both a full time student and an elementary school tutor?” he asked, as he looked at me in the eyes trying to stare down his own nervousness.
“I realize the amount of stress many would think that I am about to put on my plate, but I do not see working in an elementary school as being terribly stressful. My only fear is that I will not be a good tutor or not be able to help in the way that I want to.” I replied, with my voice shaking even more than his did, hoping that he would still hear my sincerity underneath my fleeting words.
I assured him that I knew that I would be responsible enough to handle both worlds and still be able to let the children be a focus. Chris then smiled at me, eagerly presented his, now only damp, hand to me, shook my hand and said, “Congratulations, you’re now a tutor for Philadelphia University. If you want the job, it is yours.”
I was beaming. With no prior experience tutoring, I could have never guessed that it would be that easy.
I started working at Mifflin School in mid-October. It was a medium sized school that went from kindergarten to the eighth grade, and had two floors. Located in the suburban part of Philadelphia, the school was less than half a mile away from my dormitory, and maybe a mile away from main campus. The first day that I walked into classroom 104, the room number immediately amused me because it reminded me of a cartoon that I loved to watch, ‘Kids in Room104’ I think it was called. There were two teachers in the room Mrs. Jaras and Mrs. Ilias. Mrs. Jaras was the main teacher while Mrs. Ilias was the Teacher’s Assistant. More than anything else about that day, I vividly remember going to recess with the students in my class, whom I affectionately started calling my kids. When I went out to their playground, I tried not to show my shock in reaction to the conditions that they were allowed to play. There was no grass anywhere except where it was rudely breaking through the cracks of the broken pavement, of which they called their playground. There were soda bottles, empty potato chip bags and broken glass; I did not even want to stand where these kids happily sat. I felt horrible for pitying their conditions, but I could not help but to flash back and compare it to the schools and playgrounds that I had played on when I was in the first grade. My school had a tennis/volleyball court, a basketball court, a jungle gym, a tire swing, and other solid wood fixtures with cubbies and tools that we kids could use to fuel our imaginations. I remember playing kickball on the field during recess, and sliding into home plate. Most importantly, we had grass. Lots of nice green grass. But, at Mifflin School, there was no green grass and no home plate, only black pavement with trash and broken glass for the kids to play.
Returning to First Grade
I went to room 104 after my 7:50am class let out, and before my 1:05pm, class began, everyday except Thursday. Thursday’s I had a four-hour lab so I could not go to work. Generally, from 10:00 am to 12:30 pm I was with my kids. At first, I had several children that I would work with throughout the course of the morning, then the numbers started to dwindle as I learned who were the students that needed specialized support. I would usually take one child from class for one-on-one reading sessions, three during lunch period, and one during recess – Julie. (I want to note that I do not support children losing recess in place of academics. However, as a tutor, I did not have control over their schedules) Before Julie started spending her recess with me, I noticed that she could not read. She could not even recognize her own name. That made her stand out and earn more of my time. Her problem was able to go unnoticed for so long because her best friend happened to be the class genius, Alexandra. Xandra used to ‘help’ Julie, the way that kids sometimes do, by giving her the answers so that they would be finished at the same time and, most importantly, before anyone else. Julie and Xandra sat adjacent to one another, so whenever Xandra would notice that Julie was not on the same question she would show Julie her paper.
Every weekend I would think of ways to make learning fun and effective for Julie. She was in danger of having to repeat the first grade if I could not get her reading and math skills up to grade level. Knowing the poor outcomes for Black children who repeat grades, I was going to do everything to make sure that did not happen. I made lesson plans for us to review and flash cards to help her learn her letters. Teaching Julie the alphabet was the hardest part. She had taught herself the sounds of the letters, but she had done it the logical way instead of the phonetic way such as, the letter ‘W’ making the ‘d’ sound instead of making the ‘www’ sound. Each day we would go over the alphabet focusing on the difficult letter of the day. At the end of the week, we would play word games or letter games that I had made up to reward her for all of her hard work. Her favorite game was ‘Letter Memory’. Letter Memory was played using the flash cards that I had made for her. We would randomly place the flash cards on a flat surface (such as several desks pushed together), look at them for a few seconds, then turn them face down. The object of the game was to get a matching pair. This could be done either by matching an uppercase letter with its lowercase counterpart or by matching a letter with the animal or object that starts with the letter that was turned over. Unlike ‘picture memory’, in order for the pair to count, she had to be able to say the letter and give the sound.
“I have a matching pair,” she said gleefully.
“What letter is that and what sound does it make,” I replied pointing to the capital letter W that she was holding in her left hand.
“It’s a capital W and it makes the ‘d’ sound,” she said.
“I’m sorry Julie, that is incorrect. The letter w makes the ‘www’ sound as in water,” I said.
“Okay, I didn’t get that one right. Now it’s your turn”, she said.
This game was probably just as fun for me as it was for her because it gave me so much joy to see her progressively give the correct answers. Her face would light up and she would flash her infectious smile, dimples and all and say, “Really, I got it right?”
P is for Perspective: Putting Things into Perspective
It seemed as soon as we were making the most progress everything started to fall apart. When it became apparent that Julie needed some work to be completed at home, I gave her worksheets to reinforce what we had gone over during her tutoring sessions, but she never completed them at home. If she worked on them at all, she would do so first thing in the morning before class would start and before I got there. Most of the time, however, they had not been touched at all. Mrs. Jaras suggested that I discuss my concerns with Julie’s grandmother who was Julie’s legal guardian, Julie called her mom, and she conveniently worked in the school. Therefore, the first opportunity that I got I kindly approached Mrs. Carmichael and proceeded to voice my concerns about Julie’s changes in behavior, her attitude towards learning, and her increasingly low self-esteem. Her response helped me put their home life into perspective,
“Kids will be kids and there is nothing that you can do about that. I’m doing the best that I can to raise all of my grandchildren alone.”
And that was that. I understood then Julie had a loving mother who was overwhelmed with the situation that life threw her way. Julie her school support system to change the approach and perspective on helping her. I understood that raising five grandchildren and working full time to do so, could not have been easy. Mrs. Carmichael was doing her best and relying on the school to do their part to help Julie.
E is For Empathy: Social-Emotional Foundation of Learning
During one of our many lessons, Julie started to cry out of frustration. She called herself stupid and then asked me if the only reason that she was ‘special’ enough to have me work with her was because she was dumb. She used the word special because Mrs. Jaras had told her that working with me was a special reward that she had earned for being so good. I hated what I was seeing in her eyes; in her little black eyes, there was so much pain. I wanted to erase all of her pain and replace it with unconditional love. I wanted to wrap my arms around her and say whatever I needed to say to reassure her that she was perfect in every possible way. I wanted to hold her the way that every child deserves to be held every single night and help all of her worries wash away in a river of love. I wanted to, but I did not. Instead, I wiped away the tears that were staining her little round face. I let her sit with me for a while in those feelings, simply letter her feel her feelings. Then I asked her why she would say such things. She told me that the kids in her class had been calling her stupid and dummy and teasing her. Even her siblings were making it hard for her to enjoy time at home. They would hide, rip, or tear up the worksheets that I would give her because in their eyes she was too stupid to learn anyway. She asked me,
“Am I stupid Miss LaTrice? Is the only reason that you come to visit me because I’m dumb?”
“Why would you say that,” I questioned.
“Because Tim, Mikayla, Jasmine and the rest of them called me [r - word] because I spend recess with you,” she said referring to her classmates.
“It must be really hurtful to hear those things from your classmates. That’s very unkind of them. You are not stupid. We spend recess together to help you be the best reader that you can be. I am really glad to have time with you, but maybe we should also play outside sometimes,” I said as I wiped her tears away.
As I walked home that day, I was so blinded by the tears that streamed down my face that I stopped walking for a few seconds. I sobbed so loudly that I could not even hear the horns that honked at me while I stood and cried in the middle of the street. When I finally started walking again, I was mad at – I was mad at the world. I had so much frustration inside of me towards people who could not see past their own lives long enough to hear an innocent child’s pleas for help. I was grateful that I had a mother who took interest in whether or not I could read, write, and do them both well. I was thankful that I was having the opportunity to go to college, learn, grow, and build a future for myself. I was angry that so many of my peers were ungrateful for these same things. How could anyone take something as meaningful and powerful as reading for granted? I loved to read as a child. I read any and everything that I could get my hands on from cereal boxes to books like ‘Morris the Moose Goes to School’ and ‘Ramona’ which were two of my favorites.
“While everyone else was wearing earplugs, I am supposed to be the one listening. So for the rest of the semester, I listened - she learned.”
Revealing Purpose
I felt renewed. I had always thought that I knew what I wanted to do with my life, but at that moment, I was positive. I was on earth to help children like Julie – to help adults who were once children like Julie, and to help adults understand how to support children like Julie. While everyone else is wearing earplugs, I am supposed to be the one listening. So for the rest of the semester, I listened - she learned.
By the end of the semester, Julie was reading books at and above her grade level.
It was an accomplishment that everyone said she could not do. When we started, she could not read ‘See Spot Run’. As she progressed, not only could she read ‘See Spot Run’, but also she could read books such as ‘The Frog and the Toad’ and ‘Amelia Bedelia’. I think that I was able to reassure her that she was going to be okay when I helped her to stop crying. In less than words, she told me what she needed. I am just glad that I was able to hear her. She went back to being the same happily cheerful and playful child that I had met back in October, only now it was the beginning of May.
Takeaways
That was my freshman year in college. Julie was the most influential person of my college years. Though I do not know what happened to her after she graduated to the second grade, it is still because of her that I graduated to practice psychology. She was one of the reasons why I was able to stay motivated, work 70 hours a week, and go to school full time during undergrad. Time and money, may have not allowed me to tutor other children the way that I did Julie, but she was the reason that I kept striving to reach my goals all those years ago.
Julie taught me just as much as I taught her, if not more. She taught me the importance of emotional validation, empathy, and support. Her grandmother opened my eyes to considering someone else's perspective and their life's situation. Knowing what I know about socioemotional development and mental health, I don’t think that Julie learned to read simply because of my tutoring, I think she learned because she felt safe and connected with me. She felt that her emotions mattered as much, if not more than, her ability to read. At the end of that school year, everyone looked at me and said that I was the reason that Julie succeeded, but I looked at Julie. That year I learned the power of empathy. Julie taught me that.
What has this taught you?
PlayfulLeigh (Playfully),
Dr. Dowtin
We'd love to have your comments, questions, and topic ideas. Please scroll to the bottom and leave a comment.
We're hiring! We're looking for a Maryland Licensed Graduate Professional Counselors. Set your own session rates, get access to selected paid training opportunities, and possible supervision options.
Are you looking for a therapist in Florida, Maryland, or Missouri for yourself or for your young child? How about a clinical supervisor in Maryland to obtain your LCPC hours?
Photo Creds:
Stock photos used from Wix with no identifiable photographer.